Film or Digital Wedding Photographer? An Analogue Take
The Digital vs Film Debate
It has become a hot topic, and has divided opinions, but should you go for a film photographer for your wedding, or a digital one. Or perhaps you should go for one that can do both..? Like in other aspects of your wedding planning, it can depend on a few factors.
I am very much a film wedding photographer, my website tells you that, but I try not to lean on the ‘film’ aspect too much. I prefer to say that I am a wedding photographer, I just happen to use film. Ultimately, if you like the look of my pictures, and would like similar for your wedding, then I am probably the right photographer for you, regardless of how I achieve my style. However, there can be a few things to think about from either side; some people will say that there is a risk with film, that your pictures may not turn out. Of course, that could be a possibility, but if your photographer knows their equipment and how to properly expose film for the look they are trying to achieve, then that is a very minimal risk. Having to get your film developed can also be a risk, but again, knowing how to do this properly, or in my case, knowing your film lab and having them prove time and again that they know what they are doing will minimise that risk as well.
Digital is not without risk in itself; what if a memory card corrupts, or gets lost/damaged? What if the files get damaged when transferring onto your PC? As with film, knowing your equipment and taking steps to minimise this risk means that realistically this doesn’t happen very often, and for some photographers, never at all.
And what about the people that offer both digital and film in one package? Well, imagine seeing your images and wishing that all of them were one or the other?
But this is all negative, and for no real reason, because having all these choices can only really be positive. Everyone is different, every wedding is different, so the more options available the better. So lets dive into why you may want to choose one over the other, or perhaps even both…
Taken on Kodak Portra 800 with the Yashica 635
Why Couples Choose Film
Film offers a timeless, organic look with rich tones, soft highlights, and a natural grain that can’t quite be replicated digitally. Each frame is more intentional, encouraging both photographer and couple to slow down and savour each shot. Many couples are drawn to film because it feels nostalgic and artistic, with an aesthetic that ages gracefully—perfect for creating wedding albums that feel classic and enduring. Film also handles light in a unique way, producing dreamy colours and depth, especially in natural settings or golden hour portraits.
Why Couples Choose Digital
Digital photography, on the other hand, is known for its flexibility and efficiency. It allows photographers to shoot a much larger number of images, experiment freely, and make adjustments on the spot. With digital, you can see results instantly, which is reassuring for both the couple and the photographer. It’s also incredibly versatile in post-production, making it possible to edit and retouch images in countless styles, from light and airy to dark and moody. Couples who prefer a modern, polished look often lean toward digital. Ultimately, the choice comes down to personal preference: film for artistry and timelessness, digital for convenience and adaptability.
Taken On Kodak Tri-X with the Nikon F2
I myself have only ever shot weddings on film. I have been asked to shoot digital, but I will always turn it down. And that leads us to the next point… your photographer. I have been fortunate to work with some amazing photographers, both film and digital, and I follow quite a few others that I really admire. There are some fantastic people out there, in every price bracket, and every style to suit anyone’s needs. So have a look at a few websites/socials/etc.. and speak to a few photographers, the one for you should make you feel comfortable, confident in their abilities, and in love with their work.
Taken on Ilford HP5 with the Pentax K2
Common Myths About Film Wedding Photography
There are some other things with film photography to address; although most people will agree that it does slow you down and make you think more about each shot you are taking, that doesn’t mean you will miss the spur of the moment shots. The best photographers can see a moment developing and be ready for it, that is true of all great photographers, both film and digital, and if they know their camera well enough, they will know exactly how to capture it, and quickly. The other myth that tends to come up with film is that the pictures are usually out of focus. I think this comes from the fact that most people are more likely to accept imperfect photos when they are taken on film, and they can add to the character. The old saying goes; ‘the only bad photo is the one you didn’t take’ and that is incredibly true, I would rather have an image of a moment or a person that is out of focus than no picture of them at all. But that doesn’t mean all film photos will be like that. A lot of film shooters that I know use cameras with autofocus and other modern functions, they just happen to shoot onto film rather than a digital sensor. Personally, I prefer to use fully manual, vintage, film cameras, and most of my pictures are perfectly in focus.
Talking about vintage cameras, this leads me on to my last point; it gets people interested.. The amount of guests that talk to me about my cameras, and film in general is huge, and I absolutely love it, I could talk about it for days. More often than not I will let people have a go with them, and let them get their own pictures. It’s such a great feeling when the bride and groom use my 1956 Yashica TLR to take a picture of each other, and it gets more people talking about film and photography in general, what could be bad about that..?
Ultimately, my advice would be; don’t get bogged down with the digital/film debate. The camera is just a tool, the editing is a style (I actually don’t edit my images), there are pros and cons, risk and reward, regardless of which you go for. If you like someone’s style, there is your starting point.
If you love the timeless, grainy look of film for your own wedding day, I’d love to hear about it. Get in touch, let’s talk about your day and see if I’m the right fit for you.
